Words: 4,280
Benny x Reader Warnings: disturbing and frightening scenarios, mentions of capture, mentions of blood, grief
Summary: Dean, Sam, Cas, and Benny take off after Y/N in hopes of catching her before she does something stupid…
A/N: This is a series! Part one here! I feel like I need to take a shower after writing some of the stuff in this one. *shudders* You’ll see! Prepare to be creeped?disgusted?angry?all of the above? There will be one more part at least after this one!
Your hometown looked pretty much the same. There were some new businesses that had popped up on the main commercial stretch and the continued cycling through of others in the spots that never seemed to host any one store for long, but otherwise it still felt familiar.
Being back after so much time, returning as a completely different person, was leaving you with an uncomfortable and unsettled feeling in the pit of your stomach. You drove the same route that you had driven countless times in what now felt like another lifetime. There was the gas station you used to stop at on the way home from school. On the next block your eyes landed on the barbecue place your brother used to say could cure any ailment. There was suddenly a tightness in your throat and chest and you tried to push it down. Finally you slowed your old truck and turned down a quiet residential street. Just three blocks down you turned into a driveway that led to a house set far back on a double lot.
It had sat vacant for so long that it now had a slightly forlorn look about it. The gutters needed to be cleaned out and the mature trees that hid the house largely from view were in need of trimming, but when your eyes took in the large front porch and the cheerful front door you half-expected to see your mom planting flowers in the front garden and your dad grilling out around the side. Tears welled up in your eyes and you blinked them away, doing your best to shake off the memories.